Partial vs. Total Knee Replacement: How to Know Which Is Right for You
If chronic knee pain makes daily walking difficult, you might be considering surgery. At Phoenix Orthopedic Group in Scottsdale, Arizona, we help you navigate these life-changing decisions. Dr. Robert A. Mileski specializes in advanced joint care to help you regain your mobility.
When conservative treatments no longer work, a knee replacement is often the next step. The main choice is between a partial and a total knee replacement. Both options offer excellent relief, but they serve different needs.
What is the difference between partial and total knee replacement?
A partial knee replacement resurfaces only the single damaged area of your joint, while a total replacement reconstructs the entire knee. In a partial procedure, we preserve your healthy bone, cartilage, and native ligaments. A total replacement replaces all three compartments of the knee with durable implants.
The American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons (AAOS) recommends partial replacements specifically for patients with isolated osteoarthritis on one side of the knee. If your joint damage is widespread, a total replacement is the safer, more reliable option. At our Scottsdale clinic, we use detailed imaging to map your joint damage precisely.
Does a partial knee replacement feel more natural?
Yes, patients who get a partial knee replacement often report that the joint feels more natural during daily activities. This is because the procedure preserves your native cruciate ligaments, which maintain your natural joint stability and movement.
A 2025 study in the Journal of Clinical Medicine evaluated 4,500 knees. It found that patients with partial replacements had lower joint awareness than those with total replacements. This means they were more likely to forget they had an artificial joint while walking or climbing stairs. At our practice, we focus on tissue-sparing techniques to help you achieve this natural movement whenever possible.
What are the long-term trade-offs of each option?
The primary trade-off involves how long the implant lasts before you might need a second surgery. While a partial replacement offers a quicker recovery, a total knee replacement historically provides a more durable, permanent solution.
A 2026 study in the Journal of Arthroplasty tracked over 108,000 patients. It found a 12% revision rate at 10 years for partial replacements, compared to 5% for total replacements. Because osteoarthritis can progress in the untreated areas of a partial knee, some patients eventually require a conversion to a total replacement. We work closely with you to weigh these long-term risks against your immediate lifestyle goals.
Choosing the right surgery requires a personalized evaluation of your unique anatomy and activity level. If you’re ready to find relief from chronic joint pain, schedule a visit with our team today by calling 602-277-1558 or booking online.
You Might Also Enjoy...
Medial Approach Robotic Knee Surgery: Why Less Pain Means Faster Recovery
The Science Behind PRP: When Is It Most Effective for Joint Pain?
Treatment Options for Irreparable Rotator Cuff Tears
4 Orthopedic Problems PRP Can RelieveĀ
